How to Dodge the Most Common Negotiation Mistakes

Negotiation—oh, what a fun little game of “who can outsmart who” while trying to keep it civil. Whether you’re haggling over a car price, asking for a raise, or just trying to get your roommate to do the dishes for once, it’s a skill everyone needs. But let’s face it, the process isn’t always smooth sailing. It’s easy to fall into some all-too-common traps that can leave you walking away empty-handed or, worse, agreeing to something you didn’t even want.

Think about it: ever started a negotiation thinking, “I got this,” only to realize halfway through that you’ve somehow agreed to split the last slice of pizza? Yep, we’ve all been there. Negotiating might look straightforward, but in reality, it’s one part preparation, one part communication, and a sprinkle of “please don’t say something awkward.” The good news? Most mistakes aren’t unavoidable disasters—they’re just bumps in the road.

And hey, mistakes happen to everyone, even the pros. But that doesn’t mean you have to keep repeating them. A little awareness can save you a lot of headaches. So, let’s break it down and figure out how to sidestep those classic negotiation faceplants.

Failing to Prepare

Walking into a negotiation without prepping is like showing up to a potluck with nothing but an empty Tupperware—awkward and not exactly a power move.

You can’t just wing it and hope for the best; that’s a recipe for disaster. Preparation is everything, my friend. It’s about more than just knowing what you want—it’s about knowing the playing field.

Before you even think about sitting down at the table, you’ve gotta do your homework. Who are you dealing with? What do they want? What’s the going rate for whatever you’re haggling over? Basically, if you don’t know what you’re walking into, you’re setting yourself up to get steamrolled. It’s like trying to win trivia night without even glancing at the category list—good luck with that.

And don’t forget to figure out what your own non-negotiables are. Are you going to stand firm on that salary number? Is there any wiggle room on the deadline you’re pushing for? Knowing what matters most to you can save you from that awkward moment where you agree to something and immediately regret it.

Also, pro tip: jot some notes down. No, you’re not writing a thesis, but having key points in front of you can be a lifesaver when your brain decides to suddenly take a coffee break mid-negotiation. Trust me, a little preparation now will save you a lot of head-scratching later.

Ignoring the Other Party’s Needs

Picture this: you’re at a coffee shop, trying to split a muffin with a friend. You grab the knife and carve out the bigger half for yourself without even asking if they might want, I don’t know, the side with all the chocolate chips. That’s kind of what it feels like when you head into a negotiation without giving a second thought to what the other person might need. Sure, it’s tempting to stay laser-focused on your own goals—it’s your muffin, after all—but if you’re not considering what the other side wants, you’re setting the stage for some serious awkwardness.

The thing is, negotiations aren’t one-sided. Shocking, I know. It’s not just about what you’re asking for; it’s about creating a situation where both sides can walk away feeling like they didn’t just lose an arm and a leg. The other party isn’t a robot—they have needs, concerns, and goals too. Maybe they’re dealing with budget constraints, a tight deadline, or just trying to save face in front of their boss. Whatever it is, if you’re not paying attention, you’re going to miss key clues that could help you find some common ground.

The best way to figure this out? Listen. Like, actually listen. Not the kind where you’re just waiting for your turn to talk, but the kind where you’re picking up on what they’re really saying. You’d be surprised how much smoother things go when the other person feels heard.

Being Overly Aggressive

Look, we all want to come out on top, but coming in hot like a freight train isn’t exactly the secret sauce to negotiation success.

If your strategy involves bulldozing over the other person until they just give in, well…that’s not negotiating—that’s just being, uh, “a bit much.” You don’t want to leave the other side feeling steamrolled or, worse, plotting their revenge because you made them agree to something they hated. Trust me, nobody likes that person who treats every conversation like it’s a courtroom drama.

Instead of throwing your weight around, try dialing it back a notch. A little charm and patience go a long way. Sure, you want to be firm about what matters to you, but there’s a huge difference between being confident and being, well, a complete buzzkill. People are more likely to meet you halfway if they don’t feel like they’re being cornered into submission. Plus, keeping things friendly doesn’t mean you’re giving up power; it just shows you know how to play the long game.

Oh, and remember: if the other person’s clamming up or giving you those “I’m just nodding to get this over with” vibes, it’s a red flag that you might’ve gone a bit overboard. Back off just a smidge—negotiation isn’t about winning every single point. It’s about making a deal that actually sticks.

Not Setting Clear Goals

So imagine walking into a restaurant, starving, and when the waiter asks what you want, you just shrug and say, “Eh, food.”

Guess what? You’re probably gonna end up with something you don’t even like, and that’s basically what happens when you go into a negotiation without clear goals. You’ve gotta know what you’re aiming for, or you’ll end up agreeing to who-knows-what and wondering how you got there.

Think about it—are you asking for a raise or just hoping they’ll “do something nice for you”? Are you trying to buy a car or just see how much you can sweet-talk off the price? Vague goals are like trying to order off a menu written in a language you don’t speak—confusing and a little dangerous. So, take a second to figure out what your non-negotiables are. Whether it’s a salary number, a delivery timeline, or even who gets the last slice of pizza, be specific.

And don’t just wing it thinking you’ll “figure it out as you go.” Spoiler alert: you won’t. Go in with a clear plan so you’re not left agreeing to something totally random, like trading a weekend off for…an office plant. Goals, my friend. They’re not optional.

Letting Emotions Take Over

Now, let’s be real—negotiations can feel like a rollercoaster of emotions.

One second you’re cool, calm, and collected, and the next you’re ready to flip the table because someone just lowballed you like it’s a garage sale. It happens. But letting your feelings run the show? Big mistake. Anger, frustration, or even excitement can totally cloud your judgment, and before you know it, you’ve either agreed to something ridiculous or stormed out without a deal at all. Not ideal.

Here’s the thing: staying chill is the name of the game. If you feel like you’re about to lose it—whether it’s because they’re driving a hard bargain or you’re just hangry—find a way to hit pause. Grab some water, take a deep breath, pretend to check your email, whatever works. You don’t have to let them know you’re internally screaming.

And hey, it’s not just about anger—getting overly excited can trip you up too. Ever been so pumped about a “great deal” that you agreed before realizing it wasn’t so great? Yeah, that’s the kind of emotional slip-up we’re trying to avoid. Keep your poker face on, even if your brain is doing cartwheels.

Failure to Consider Alternatives

Let’s talk about backup plans because, honestly, putting all your eggs in one basket is just asking for a mess.

In a negotiation, you’ve got to have a backup—or three. What if the other person flat-out says no, or worse, offers you something so outlandish you have to laugh just to keep from crying? That’s where having options comes in handy. It’s like walking into an ice cream shop and finding out they’re out of your favorite flavor—do you leave sad and empty-handed, or do you pivot to chocolate chip and move on with your day?

Knowing your alternatives isn’t just smart; it’s empowering. If the deal on the table isn’t cutting it, being able to confidently say, “Alright, I’ve got other options,” flips the script in your favor. Whether it’s another job offer, a different supplier, or just being prepared to walk away, having a Plan B (and maybe a Plan C) keeps you from feeling cornered.

The best part? You might not even need to use your backup plan, but just knowing you’ve got one can give you that extra boost of confidence. So, before you head into your next negotiation, take a second to ask yourself, “What’s my next move if this one doesn’t pan out?” Because winging it is not a strategy, my friend.

Selling a property? Give us a call today and learn more about our professional photography services that can boost your property listing!

Also, explore our sister company for exclusive luxury listings you won’t want to miss. Don’t forget to tune into our new podcast for even more valuable insights!